"Keep the Cat Free"

17.05.2012

FELIX

The student voice of Imperial College London since 1949

The Hell of Heaven

Is paradise all it's cracked up to be?
Samuel Horti
Sharing
Sam Horti NEW.jpg

The question of what happens to us after we die is one that has troubled us as a species for thousands of years, and to this day many among us still wrestle daily with our own doubt and confusion over the matter. The posthumously themed wonderings of religious movements and philosophers alike have produced many weird and wonderful ideas filled with fantasy and creativity. The conspicuously man-made nature of the afterlife as displayed in modern religions isn’t something that I feel it would be worthwhile to investigate at great length, mainly because of the fact that it is so palpable that the term “flogging a dead horse” comes to mind. The grubby fingerprints of mankind are present wherever you look.

To give a brief example, I would invite you to call to mind a fundamental belief that many religious people will espouse; specifically the idea that your own immaterial soul (whatever that means) leaves your body to travel onto the afterlife after your body has expired. The religions of our time do not seem to have quite the required imagination to free their minds of the earthly shackles that bind them, and therefore we are left with a post mortem experience which may evoke fear or joy in highly developed primates, but would have no effect on an immaterial soul. The eternal fires of hell proclaimed in the gospels can be extinguished when you realise that a soul has no skin to feel the pain of a burn, and I’m afraid the promised virgins in the Islamic Jannah (paradise) are going to have to remain distinctly unsatisfied for obvious reasons.

Taking part in this everlasting horror show isn’t something that I could possibly wish on my worst enemy, let alone myself.

What the concept of an eternal heaven gives many people is hope of a better existence. By simply doing good on the earth and acting in accordance with the teachings of your chosen celestial leader, you can achieve perfection after you pass away. Leaving aside the implications this has for morality (what would happen without the promise of heaven?), I would like to ask those of you who hope for an afterlife a simple question. Would you enjoy heaven? Whenever I have asked myself this question, the answer is always a resounding no. Heaven would quite simply be hell to me.

What heaven gives us is the offer of a never-ending existence, and personally, I do not wish to exist for eternity. The thought of being trapped behind the bars of being is to me a horrifying one, however great my existence might turn out to be. After all, after my “soul” has spent 20 million years inside the pearly gates, I think it may struggle to find something to do for fun. As If anyone tells you that they wish to exist forever then it is safe to say that infinity is not a concept they have firmly grasped. Otherwise, it must be accepted that they wish to inhabit a realm from which there is no escape, a realm which they desire so strongly that they are willing to pay the measly entry fee of their freedom, surely one of the most important things a “soul” possesses.

Of course this offer that heaven gives you, and that God gives you, is not an offer at all. It is an insistence. An insistence that you must spend your timeless stay endlessly praising and worshiping the ever-watching big brother. Worst of all, alongside the limitless grovelling comes a further requirement – that you must enjoy yourself in the process. This idea, that you have no choice but to have fun whilst you submit completely and selflessly to an unelected dictator, is something that I find indescribably nauseating and very creepy. As Christopher Hitchens so wonderfully puts it, it would be akin to living in a “celestial North Korea”. The difference being of course, as Hitchens himself points out is that “at least you can fucking die and leave North Korea”. Taking part in this everlasting horror show isn’t something that I could possibly wish on my worst enemy, let alone myself.

As I see it, not having an afterlife is by far and away the most attractive option. Living life as if there is nothing more to come is surely the most fulfilling and productive way to live, and even the religious pay attention to this fact. I do not know a religious person that honestly conducts themselves as if this earth is some sort of trial, one big cosmic joke to which the punch line comes in the form of slavery to the almighty God who so graciously gave us life in the first place. Only once you fully realise that this life is the only one that you’re going to get are you able to look upon the face of true freedom and embrace your ultimate independence.

Comments (4 comments)

Post a comment

Ruzky Aliyar

Friday November 04 2011 23:50

Your point on the eventual weariness of infinity is something I mulled over for many years (I'm a Muslim) and came to the conclusion that it’s only valid if what is available for us to do and experience in the hereafter is limited. Islam teaches that the Hereafter is enduring and in Heaven your supply is endless and infinite. And since there is always something new to do you will never become bored and your heaven will not become hell! If you do begin to wonder how could there be so many new things for you to do, well if infinity in time exists in the hereafter then it’s equally logical to have infinity of new experiences and things to do in it.

I don’t know why people must exert themselves to mention virgins in paradise at the first instance of the mention of Islam but I guess what’s always on the mind tends to be spoken most :P The highlight of Paradise is mentioned as seeing God.

[since I like talking about this a lot I'm going to defy the word limit and continue on a new comm

Ruzky Aliyar

Friday November 04 2011 23:50

ent] :D

And in the hereafter our souls will be in new bodies and sensation along with everything else so you will feel everything is heaven or hell.

I think you’re quite misinformed when you say that in heaven your time is spent worship. Earth is a place where you work and play to build up your account for the hereafter and the heaven is where you play and relax.

I do have one question. For the sake of discussion let us assume that the hereafter becomes weary, or whatever as you wish to believe, does this in any way disprove the existence of a Creator? I think that’s the important question.

Samuel Horti (Author)

Sunday November 06 2011 11:49

@Ruzky Aliyar: Thanks for reading and commenting, appreciate it. I mention the whole virgins thing because I thought that was a good example of humans, in their limited imagination, projecting their own wants and desires onto a supposedly divine construct. It was to emphasize the clear man made nature of heaven by showing how it is constructed to appeal to humans' emotions.

On the eventual weariness, I would say that it doesn't matter that there are unlimited possibilities. One thing has to be constant: existence. It is the fact that you must carry on existing even if you do not want to. Even if you get to a point at which you do not want to exist, you are condemned to carry on existing. In essence, you are limited in your choice and have no true freedom, because you are bound by existence.

And no, this doesn't disprove a creator, but the aim of the article was to answer the question of whether we would enjoy heaven as current religions propose it.

Ruzky Aliyar

Wednesday November 09 2011 13:05

Wouldn't it make sense for a Creator to know the likes/dislikes of the creation and mention these as rewards/otherwise? And in heaven if you do not want something then you do not have to have it - no one will be forced to have 70 virgins!

It’s interesting to note that this is only mentioned for the martyrs (and God knows who are the true martyrs) - and in Islamic and non-Islamic cases the vast majority of soldiers that have died and continue to die are men and it makes sense for God to mention something that would they like. And like I said no one will be forced to have 70 virgins if they don’t want to! What the Quran emphasises throughout is to do good and strive to enter heaven with your spouse, family and everyone you love.

I knew I forgot to mention something. Islam teaches that in heaven you can have whatever you wish for. So if you want to cease to exist then you'll have your wish granted! But I guess people would mostly opt for continued existence and continued enjoyment! :D

Comment anonymously or log in

Anonymous comments are moderated before appearing on the website. Comments posted while logged in appear immediately and are moderated later. Read our commenting policy for more information.

Commenting Policy

Felix is fully supportive of fierce and frank discussions. We will generally allow comments that are on-topic and avoid personal attacks; criticising someone's decision is allowed, criticising their weight, for example, is not.

Comments may be deleted/rejected if they:

  • are off-topic
  • contain ad-hominem attacks
  • are potentially libellous
  • use excessively foul language
  • are obviously spam

Email article

The Hell of Heaven
(Seperate multiple address with a comma)