"Keep the Cat Free"

23.02.2012

FELIX

The student voice of Imperial College London since 1949

Concerns over future of Humanities

Lecturer speaks out against "departmental cuts"
Sharing
human.jpg
The Department of Humanities has spent the last three years in a state of
- Credit: Jonathan Peek

Concerns have been raised about the future of the Humanities department at Imperial by one of its lecturers, Didier Occhipinti. Mr Occhipinti, who teaches French at the College, was due to present a lecture to the Political Philosophy Society late last term but cancelled the event in protest of what he sees as the threat of a "death by a thousand cuts" to the department.

Speaking to Felix Mr Occhipinti raised the issue of "things at the College with which [he feels] more and more disturbed with".  He believes that "discrimination to humanities is on the increase", and that this sort of "anti-intellectualism can go hand in hand with elitism". This discrimination has manifested itself in Humanities department having spent the past three years in a state of near "permanent restructuring" – the much debated proposed changes to the College timetable being just the latest example following large cuts in previous years.

These latest proposals are a particular concern of Charmian Brinson, the department's Director of Language Studies. She says that the “College Day proposals as they stand will have the effect of reducing student options and adversely affecting the overall student experience just at the point when student fees are about to be tripled”. Professor Brinson also points out “Humanites Department was not represented on the College Day Committee” and that while the former Head of the Department, Professor Andrew Warwick, was invited to one of Committee’s sessions “the points he made at the meeting were not incorporated into the College Day document”.

Mr Occhipinti stresses that, whilst on their own the various changes to Humanities are reasonable; together they pose a real threat to the Department. He believes that “by toying with Humanities the way management is doing a tipping point will be reached from which Humanities will not recover” and that there is a “real divide between senior management and students & lecturers” who support humanities. Felix was shown a student comment from last autumn's SOLE survey which bemoaned how “departments officially encourage humanities, but in practice, do almost anything to discourage students from taking any course (or at least attentively keeping up with it)”.

He says that he does not understand the false divide between sciences and humanities and points out how beneficial the subjects taught by the Department can be to Imperial students. He points to a quote from the Observer which he thinks explains it best: “The study of history, philosophy, languages and literature broadens horizons and animates minds that go on to enrich society in many ways. The advantages that flow from research into the creative output of humanity might not be obviously financial, but they are incalculable.”

Comments (7 comments)

Post a comment

YearInEurope

Friday January 20 2012 11:23

As a Year in Europe student, I’ve experienced first-hand the changes happening in the Humanities Department and I too believe that the constant departmental re-structuring is posing a very real threat to is future. Luckily, there are people at Imperial who, like Mr Occhipinti, realise the importance of their subject and are prepared to fight for its worth.

I consider the Humanities Department to be one of Imperial’s greatest assets, primarily as it succeeds in developing the creative minds of its students in what is otherwise a strictly science-based community. The result? Students emerging from Humanities come with a true breadth of knowledge and character that extends further from the resounding Imperial College stereotype of “I’m a Scientist and that’s that”.

A. Student

Friday January 20 2012 17:25

I'm also a Year in Europe so I've been studying French in the Humanities Department for two years now. I can say with confidence that the teaching I've received has been excellent and I feel I've greatly benefited from the experience. However the re-structuring of the department may well prevent or discourage others from following a similar course. This for me is a great shame and will be a detriment to future students.

You need to have an edge in today's job market and perhaps having studied a course in politics or proficiency in a foreign language might be the difference between landing that job or not.

It's this one

Friday January 20 2012 18:28

Despite Monsieur Occhipinti's tortured abstraction of 'anti-intellectualism going hand in hand with elitism' like the world's worst god-parents, he's absolutely right about the rest. When Imperial could offer world-class education and literate, creative, employable graduates, it chooses to cut the icing off the cake. When Imperial's student satisfaction is sitting at the bottom of a test tube crying itself to sleep, they stop adding fun potion. And most importantly when their own bread and butter turns to ashes in their mouths, as Imperial plummets flailing down the league tables (thanks to student satisfaction), the management are busy pulling the escape ladder quickly up the other way as fast as they can. When they could provide the best, they turn their backs on potential and make do with the curled old canapes of ambition. Even if you don't fancy a slice of the humanities pie yourself, you should be very angry.

Anonymous

Saturday January 21 2012 13:35

Another slow clap for the senior management at Imperial College London. Is there nothing the student union can do to send a clear message that these short sighted people are destroying our university? They are seemingly unable to understand that we are at university to have our minds enriched, not merely to train as competent engineers and get high paying city jobs.

What a waste of time it will be for future students to come to Imperial Vocational College of Banking and Management.

What is happening? 1

Sunday January 22 2012 13:53

Since my start at Imperial I have experienced the passion that people put into learning languages, both students and staff members show a big interest in the courses offered my the humanities department. The humanities departement is a vital part of the transmission of knowledge at our College. Imperial constantly advertises the international background of our students and staff members, but a key part of giving people the opportunity to benefit from this rich environnement and exchange cultures are the language classes. If only the people taking these decision would know

What is happening? 2

Sunday January 22 2012 13:53

But it is not only the welfare and desire of the students to learn languages that should be given attention to, it is also the fact that today's professional world doesn't look for narrow minded scientist, they want well rounded people that are able to look over the edge. Very realistically, putting the courses 5 - 7 pm will make it impossible for most of the students to attend. What is happening there? Imperial will also loose a bit of its attractiveness. I must say that the opportunity of taking language and politics courses was one of the points that convinced me to chose Imperial.

Last but not least, a big thank you to the teachers and stuff of the humanities departement,who continue to deliver excellent classes even though they have to suffer under all the restructuring and cuts. Without their continuous effort and extracurricular commitement we would have felt a lot more the dangerous decisions that have been taken.

I love humanities

Sunday January 22 2012 16:22

@It's this one: Ever thought of using a metaphor?

Comment anonymously or log in

Anonymous comments are moderated before appearing on the website. Comments posted while logged in appear immediately and are moderated later. Read our commenting policy for more information.

Commenting Policy

Felix is fully supportive of fierce and frank discussions. We will generally allow comments that are on-topic and avoid personal attacks; criticising someone's decision is allowed, criticising their weight, for example, is not.

Comments may be deleted/rejected if they:

  • are off-topic
  • contain ad-hominem attacks
  • are potentially libellous
  • use excessively foul language
  • are obviously spam

Email article

Concerns over future of Humanities
(Seperate multiple address with a comma)