Culture

Not exactly a Booker novel

David Carr on the shortcomings of this year's Man Booker prize winner

Not exactly a Booker novel

Last week saw Julian Barnes claim the Man Booker for his short novel ‘The Sense of an Ending’ in what has been derided as the worst shortlist in the prize’s 43 year history. No doubt this was caused in part by the judges’ reward for readability; a strange requirement for the pre-eminent award for literary fiction in the UK.

‘Sense’ treads familiar territory – middle-aged, middle-class pondering on memory and death – such is the scope of modern British literature. Tony Webster is a retired divorcé contemplating the passivity of his life when a letter from the past resurfaces, causing him to re-evaluate his actions, or rather his memories of them. What comes next is a psychologically acute but oddly unbelievable retrospective of his rememberings; of what he has forgotten, and what he has chosen to forget.

Barnes’ story touches thematically on Kazuo Ishiguro’s ‘The Remains of the Day’ and ‘On Chesil Beach’ by Ian McEwan (both Booker winning writers – though McEwan won for a different book). However, ‘Sense’ lacks the pathos of Ishiguro’s unreliable narrator and the subtlety of McEwan’s interweaved narrative.

‘Sense of an Ending’ treads familiar territory ... such is the scope of modern British literature

Andrew Motion, the former Poet Laureate and last year’s Booker head judge, said that amongst the dire shortlist, Barnes’ novel was the clear winner, though his panel did select Howard Jacobson’s similarly middle-of-the-road ‘The Finkler Question’. It makes you wonder if perhaps the list was compiled only to give Barnes his just desserts; after all, this was his fourth nomination for the prize and his first win.

The Sense of an Ending’ is not a bad book. It is faultlessly written, and at times beautifully so, but in its constant exposition it often feels more like an extended essay than a full-blooded work of fiction. Surely to win a prize this big a novel must have a good chance of making it into the English Canon, and this one just does not fit the bill.

From Issue 1499

28th Oct 2011

Discover stories from this section and more in the list of contents

Explore the edition

Read more

Peter Haynes to take over Provost role in October

News

Peter Haynes to take over Provost role in October

Professor Peter Haynes has been appointed as the new Provost and Deputy President of Imperial College. The current  Vice-Provost for Education and Student Experience, Haynes will succeed the outgoing Provost, Professor Ian Walmsley, who has served in the role since 2018. Imperial President Hugh Brady said Professors Haynes and Walmsley

By Guillaume Felix
Why RAG’s bungee jump event never took place

News

Why RAG’s bungee jump event never took place

Earlier this academic year, Imperial Raising and Giving (RAG), had announced the return of their charity bungee jump after a hiatus of 10 years. The event, however, was postponed several times, and Felix can now reveal why it was cancelled. The event, initially scheduled for November 13th, was postponed several

By Mohammad Majlisi and Nadeen Daka
Palestine protests ramp up as year ends and tensions rise

News

Palestine protests ramp up as year ends and tensions rise

Saturday 7th June: Pro-Palestinian protestors hold banners as they stand on ALERT at the Great Exhibition Road Festival. Tuesday 10th June: A student announces a hunger strike asking for Imperial to investigate Islamophobia and anti-Arab racism, form a student-staff working group on ethical investment, and divest from arms companies accused

By Mohammad Majlisi