Film & TV

The lady doth protest too much

Maggie Smith is acerbic and rancid in this Alan Bennett-scripted film

The lady doth protest too much

The reputation _The Lady in the Van _has gained in the run up to its release can perhaps be best illustrated by the fact that during a recent phone-call to my grandma – a woman in her late 80s whose closest cinema is the civic centre, where all films are released 3 months later than anywhere else – she mentioned that she was very excited to go and see it. This is what happens when you blend together director Nicholas Hynter, actor Maggie Smith, and playwright Alan Bennett: you get a national treasure smoothie, palatable to all.

But while this may be the reputation the film is conjuring up, the actual product is far from populist. Maggie Smith plays Miss Shepherd, an elderly vagabond with a past, whose malodorous presence inflames Mornington Crescent’s residents’ liberal guilt and innate disgust in equal measure. Taking up residence in Alan Bennett’s driveway, she remains there for 15 years, much to the chagrin of neighbours. Alex Jennings is well cast as Bennett, retaining the Yorkshire playwright’s social mannerisms that have become so well established over the years, but Maggie Smith is the real star of the show; her character is certainly sympathetic, but Smith never lets this spill over into sentimentality, a permanent sneer etched around her mouth.

Certain aspects of the film don’t quite work: a backstory involving a sinister figure from Shepherd’s past would be better left out, and the idea to have two versions of Alan Bennett’s character – the writer and the man – does not work as well as it could have, although it is an interesting touch. Hytner, fresh from his tenure at the National Theatre, where he directed Maggie Smith in the first stage performance of The Lady in the Van, does a very good job at conjuring up the complex social interactions for which the North London elite have become famous. It is a film that goes down smooth, leaving a sensation of warm contentment – definitely one you can take the granny to.

Verdict: 3.5 Stars

From Issue 1618

20th Nov 2015

Discover stories from this section and more in the list of contents

Explore the edition

Read more

How the Supreme Court ruling on gender is impacting queer people at Imperial

News

How the Supreme Court ruling on gender is impacting queer people at Imperial

Last month, the UK Supreme Court (UKSC) ruled that for the purposes of the Equality Act 2010 (EA 2010), the definition of a woman is based on biological sex.  The case brought before the court, For Women Scotland Ltd v The Scottish Ministers, asked if transgender women should be included

By Oscar Mitcham and Isabella Duchovny
College opens Imperial Global India in Bengaluru

News

College opens Imperial Global India in Bengaluru

Imperial College London has launched its fourth global hub in Bengaluru. The hub will host research programmes with Indian partners, focusing on some of “the world’s most pressing challenges in areas such as climate change and sustainability, food and water security, and antimicrobial resistance (AMR).” Launched at the Science

By Mohammad Majlisi