Science

Further evidence that oil company ExxonMobil misled the public on climate change

Harvard University researchers have responded to the oil and gas giant’s criticism of their 2017 peer-reviewed analysis, which showed that ExxonMobil has misled the public about the severity of climate change.

Harvard University researchers have responded to the oil and gas giant’s criticism of their 2017 peer-reviewed analysis, which showed that ExxonMobil has misled the public about the severity of climate change. 

In 2017, Geoffrey Supran and Naomi Oreskes from the Department of the History of Science at Harvard University published their analysis of ExxonMobil’s climate change communications between 1977 and 2014. They performed “empirical document-by-document textual content analysis of 187 climate change communications from ExxonMobil”. Their analysis found that the publicly available communications produced by the company, and in particular, the editorial-style advertisements they released (referred to as “advertorials” in their research), contained expressions of doubt about climate change being real and caused by human activity. 

While 83% of peer-reviewed papers and 80% of internal documents produced by ExxonMobil acknowledged that climate change is “real and human-caused”, just 12% of advertorials acknowledged this. In fact, 81% of these advertisements expressed doubt about anthropogenic global warming. The researchers concluded that, while ExxonMobil was contributing to advancing climate science, they were simultaneously promoting doubt in the public mind about the existence of climate change. 

In the same academic journal where this study was published, ExxonMobil President Vijay Swarup published a criticism of Supran and Oreskes’s research. Swarup claimed that the analysis only assessed a small subset of the available advertorials in the New York Times, and that the original publication “obscured the separateness of… Exxon and Mobil”, who are technically two corporations. 

Supran and Oreskes have now published a response to these criticisms, and have in fact showed that the ExxonMobil’s communications were even more misleading than they initially thought. They have rebutted both of Supran’s key criticisms, noting that only 4% or less of all advertorials published by Mobil and ExxonMobil Corp in the New York Times had any discussion of anthropogenic climate change, and explaining that the original study explicitly attributed each of the advertorials assessed to Exxon, Mobil or ExxonMobil Corp. The new research shows that Exxon and Mobil both separately misled the public, and continued to do so following their merger into ExxonMobil Corp. 

Supran and Oreske also note that following the publication of their initial study, they became aware of additional relevant articles (which were highlighted by Swarup in his criticisms). Their new research shows that these additional materials actually strengthen the argument that Exxon, Mobil and ExxonMobil Corp misled the public, and provide greater evidence that all three companies published communications expressing doubt about anthropogenic climate change. 

From Issue 1752

23rd Oct 2020

Discover stories from this section and more in the list of contents

Explore the edition

Read more

Peter Haynes to take over Provost role in October

News

Peter Haynes to take over Provost role in October

Professor Peter Haynes has been appointed as the new Provost and Deputy President of Imperial College. The current  Vice-Provost for Education and Student Experience, Haynes will succeed the outgoing Provost, Professor Ian Walmsley, who has served in the role since 2018. Imperial President Hugh Brady said Professors Haynes and Walmsley

By Guillaume Felix
Why RAG’s bungee jump event never took place

News

Why RAG’s bungee jump event never took place

Earlier this academic year, Imperial Raising and Giving (RAG), had announced the return of their charity bungee jump after a hiatus of 10 years. The event, however, was postponed several times, and Felix can now reveal why it was cancelled. The event, initially scheduled for November 13th, was postponed several

By Mohammad Majlisi and Nadeen Daka
Palestine protests ramp up as year ends and tensions rise

News

Palestine protests ramp up as year ends and tensions rise

Saturday 7th June: Pro-Palestinian protestors hold banners as they stand on ALERT at the Great Exhibition Road Festival. Tuesday 10th June: A student announces a hunger strike asking for Imperial to investigate Islamophobia and anti-Arab racism, form a student-staff working group on ethical investment, and divest from arms companies accused

By Mohammad Majlisi