FELIX

"Keep the Cat Free"
20/06/13

Inspired by Iron Man

Marvin Tan Xing Haw, Physics student at Imperial, has applied for a patent for a novel way to make electricity
Sharing
Science3.jpg

A first year Physics student at Imperial has applied for a patent on a new way to make electricity. Felix Science caught up with inventor Marvin Tan Xing Haw to find out all about his (as yet hypothetical) device…

Could you tell us a bit about your invention?

It produces electricity, with power output between that of a betavoltaic battery and a nuclear fission reactor. The power output is unknown because nobody has published the results of its computational simulation yet. It works very much like a fission reactor and a betavoltaic battery.

Fission reactors sustain a chain reaction by using neutrons to induce the fission of Uranium-235. This in turn generates even more neutrons. Betavoltaic cells utilise the beta radiation from the natural decay of beta-radioisotopes like Tritium, and these beta particles transfer their energy to electrons in a diode and thus induce a voltage and current.

The use of a semiconductor diode to convert energy from beta particles to electricity is analogous to using a diode as a solar cell (converting sunlight to electricity). Combing fission and betavoltaics, neutrons are used to artificially induce fission in the beta-radioisotope, forcing the latter to produce more beta particles than it would if it relied purely on beta decay. It’s analogous to force-feeding a goose that lays golden eggs so that you get more eggs!

How did you come up with the idea?

I was really inspired last year after watching Iron Man and Iron Man 2. The world needs a small but powerful energy source like Tony Stark’s Arc Reactor. How are vehicles going to be propelled after petroleum runs out? After daydreaming long and hard about the current technologies that can approximate Stark’s Arc Reactor, I thought of combining the best of both from fission and betavoltaics.

How far into development are you?

The design needs to be perfected via computational simulation to find the optimal thickness and concentrations of the isotopes. Then, it needs to be tested experimentally. I don’t have the resources to carry out these two modes of research, so I’m stuck at the conceptual stage.

Have you had any interest from scientists who think this could work?

Some scientists told me that the idea is interesting, but they said they’re too busy with their own work and hence don’t have the time to explore it. Patent publications are not as widely read as research journals, so until a journal article has been published on my work, it’s hard to capture the attention of the scientific community.

Finally, do you have any tips for any students who might have an idea they’d like to develop?

Keep it top secret until your patent specification has been published. It’s stressful to balance your time between writing your patent specification and studying for an undergraduate degree, so time management is important. Also, use an image editor with layering capabilities (like Adobe Photoshop) to draw your patent diagrams.

Follow Marvin's progress on his Facebook page.

Comments (16 comments)

Post a comment

Anonymous

Wednesday June 20 2012 16:21

You know publishing something before having a patent approved invalidates the patent right?

Anonymous

Wednesday June 20 2012 16:48

@Anonymous Wed 20 June 16.21
I don't think a news article is quite the same as the knowledge for the invention being in the public domain. For starters, there is no mention of any of the specifics which make the intellectual property unique.

Sounds good though - I'd be interested if Felix would follow this over the course of the students career at Imperial (and beyond). I anticipate full marks on the Research Interfaces course in fourth year ;-)

Nope

Wednesday June 20 2012 16:50

http://www.ipo.gov.uk/factpublication.pdf

GG

Wednesday June 20 2012 17:02

@Anonymous: You know discussing the basic concepts of something isn't the same as the nitty-gritty in the patent, right?

Jeff Bridges

Wednesday June 20 2012 17:04

TONY STARK WAS ABLE TO BUILD THIS IN A CAVE...! WITH A BOX OF SCRAAAAAAPS!

Alexander Karapetian

Wednesday June 20 2012 17:09

Marvin has a Facebook page for his device, it would appear his patent has been granted:

https://www.facebook.com/betafission

Anonymous

Wednesday June 20 2012 17:41

Whether or not this is classed as publication, this chap will not be granted a patent until he can demonstrate that it actually works.

Marvin

Wednesday June 20 2012 19:03

Hi all!
thanks for your interest!

I filed for the patent in Dec 2011, it was published in March 2012.
Haha of course i only made it known to Felix after the patent application was published, not before.
The link to the official patent publication is on the facebook page, the search & examination report is on the last page of the PDF publication:
http://www.ipo.gov.uk/p-find-publication-getPDF.pdf?PatentNo=GB2484028&DocType=A&JournalNumber=6410

Please do feel free to post any Questions on the Facebook page.

Brennan

Wednesday June 20 2012 21:33

@Anonymous: The only way it would invalidate the patent is if prior art existed. Explaining something like that on paper does not count as prior art. Plus, you can show off a technology after applying for the patent, without receiving the patent, and have it not invalidated. That is what Sergey Brin and Google did with Google Goggles.

PatentExaminer

Wednesday June 20 2012 23:13

@Anonymous: Publishing something prior to the application date of your patent application would likely cause problems, as it could then be used as prior art against your application under 35 USC 102(a) and (e), but that's the extent of it.

Oogle Ogles

Wednesday June 20 2012 23:47

this is insane in the membrane and further work must be done

Anthony Edward Stark

Thursday June 21 2012 05:30

So why not use Thorium instead of Uranium. Thorium is easier to find and far more energy conductive. It's, what, in the top 5 most common elements found on Earth, also it transfers energy like a goddamn pro. Learn your science.

Anthony Edward Stark

Thursday June 21 2012 05:43

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uK367T7h6ZY

jacob marshall

Thursday June 21 2012 06:32

How much waste do u think it would produce? just curiouse.

jacob marshall

Thursday June 21 2012 21:11

Because if u have a problem with to much waste in a tiny little cylinder, u might want to look into thorium.

Meh

Sunday June 24 2012 21:36

Its doesn't use unobtanium...

Comment anonymously or log in

Anonymous comments are moderated before appearing on the website. Comments posted while logged in appear immediately and are moderated later. Read our commenting policy for more information.

Commenting Policy

Felix is fully supportive of fierce and frank discussions. We will generally allow comments that are on-topic and avoid personal attacks; criticising someone's decision is allowed, criticising their weight, for example, is not.

Comments may be deleted/rejected if they:

  • are off-topic
  • contain ad-hominem attacks
  • are potentially libellous
  • use excessively foul language
  • are obviously spam

Email article

Inspired by Iron Man
(Seperate multiple address with a comma)