Opinion

A dangerous step backwards

...our minds, will keep on ‘involving’, until we return to the dark ages where knowledge and logic were too scared to fight mythology and bullshit.

A dangerous step backwards

In 1615, Galileo was tried and convicted by the Italian inquisition for his unorthodox views on the heliocentrism of our solar system. His denial to comply and bend over before the established power threw him into house arrest until the end of his life. However, it also sparked a scientific revolution, an attempt to distance knowledge from established sayings, dogmas and stories, whilst giving birth to one of the brightest periods of humanity. For the first time, knowledge and the logical search for truth was put ahead of fairy tales and excuses to sit on gold thrones under marble cupules.

what amazes me is how easily authorities punish a scientist for wrongly predicting something, but let any CEO walk away freely after their wrong 'predictions' collapse entire economies

Now, it seems, Italy has decided that science’s nice and fruitful run has reached its end, and decided to return to its old methods of castration of the intellect and witch hunting.

I understand that the press is probably not reporting the case in the right way; that there was probably avoidance and trampling of established emergency protocols under seismological alerts; that if the scientists did not mess up the ‘advice’ they gave on whether the whole town was going to disappear off the face of the Earth or not, plenty of lives might have been saved.

However, what amazes me is how easily authorities can punish a scientist for wrongly predicting something which is by definition unpredictable, yet can let ‘Nobel prize winners’ (I do not believe in Economics to be Nobel-worthy) or any big framed, patchy headed CEO walk away freely after their wrong ‘predictions’ collapse entire economies and, with them, millions of lives.

The difference between these two is exactly the same one that separates doctors from holistic reiki touch therapy scumbag con artists or pharmaceutical research from watered down solutions of watered down active components, so watered down they don’t exist anymore.

And as long as we don’t get these straight and this tendency to punish knowledge (or the attempt to achieve it) continues, our society, our minds, will keep on ‘involving’, until we return to the dark ages where knowledge and logic were too scared to fight mythology and bullshit.

From Issue 1529

2nd Nov 2012

Discover stories from this section and more in the list of contents

Explore the edition

Read more

Environment

College Fossil Fuel partners explore options in Venezuela

Since the removal of Venezuela’s autocratic leader, Nicolas Maduro, by an American task force in January, President Donald Trump has vociferously called for oil companies to rekindle their commercial ties with the embattled petrostate. Although many have been reluctant to “take the oil”, baulking at high upfront investments to

By Guillaume Felix
Lobbying by Stove Industry undermines Council Public Health Campaigns and Housing Plans

Environment

Lobbying by Stove Industry undermines Council Public Health Campaigns and Housing Plans

An investigation published by The BMJ in March reveals councils in England face legal pressure from the Stove Industry Association (SIA) as public health campaigns urge homeowners to limit the use of wood-burners. Findings from freedom of information requests, sent to local authority areas identified as having the highest density

By Ushika Kidd